ethical line

These two articles were very helpful in helping define those shades of grey between right and wrong.  Honestly, I can't believe that the photographer mentioned in the "Staged, Staging, Stages" article actually asked the athlete to recreate his exciting moment for the camera.  I would feel embarrassed to do such a thing, although this must be an extreme example. Dave Wertheimer really seems to go above and beyond in making sure he presents the truth.  Giving the truth means going the extra mile even when it is inconvenient and could cost you time, such as when he went back to the flower shop to get the story as it naturally happened.  Basically, it seems like if you have to say to your subject, "Can you do this?" or somehow influence their actions, it is crossing the line.  The subject should never have to recreate an action or feel like they are being told to act in a certain way.  Wertheimer says he tries to be a "fly on the wall" which seems to be the best way to approach it.  You might end up getting some extra footage, but it is all real and not fixed to appear a certain way to match the idea for a story in your head.  

On another note, "Sliding Sound, Altered Images" really hits the note about how the images a photographer presents to the public can dramatically affect the outcomes of events, families, and individuals.  The article talks about using file tapes sparingly and how even altering the lighting or angle of a photo can present the subject as one way or another, such as in the O.J. Simpson example.  When you alter the mood of something it can easily get into the minds of the viewers or listeners and affect them without them even noticing.

I think Al Tompkins presents a perfect way to help the reporter distinguish is he or she has made an ethical blunder.  If you would feel completely comfortable telling your editor (or teacher) exactly how you edited and got the material for the piece, then you are probably ok.  But if you would be wary to truthfully reveal your methods, then you probably crossed the line somewhere.