Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Staged, Staging, and Stages Blog By: Lindsey Weygandt

I believe Dave Wertheimer was dead on in his article "Staged, Staging, and Stages." It is unethical to make your story subjects recreate an experience, sound, or action for any news story. Staging is an issue of ethics because as journalists delivering the truth is of top priority. If we are making our sources recreate something to better our story, it is a misrepresentation and is not the complete truth. Oftentimes, the staged version would be nothing like the original action because people act differently when they are being filmed or interviewed. By telling your sources to perform a specific action you are basically telling them to act and convey false emotion. Ethics is a key component of journalism because it is how the public views the media. Journalists must practice good ethics and consistent credibility in order to truthfully serve the public.

Staging, framing and unreal events

It seems to me that there is a time and a place for everything. Staged photographs and videos do have their place; that place is not in news. I agree with the author of stage, staged, staged. Manufacturing an event in order to catch it is not valid. If you miss the event, you miss the event.

In my own reporting for this course, I have had issues with the weather. If it is cold enough to shoot, I have a class. If it’s too warm to shoot, everyone has the time and the ability to get to the work site. To accommodate the weather, I’ve come up with different ideas for my story. As opposed to focusing on construction in the winter, why not talk about how happy the bricklayers are that it’s warming up? Or, now that it’s warmer, it takes less time to prep the site?

It seems that professional photographers and videographer should follow the same tenets. If they miss the story, find a way to rework it. Frame it differently. Talk about the families suffering in the aftermath of the fire, and have them talk about their experience. See if there is b-roll you can use of the building before and after the fire as a comparison. Good news people shouldn’t have to fabricate an event. They should, however maximize the situation. If it is a scheduled interview, in a chair, light the person so that they don’t look sallow. The anchors have good lighting; why not the subjects?

As I said, there’s a time and a place for everything. Commercials, interviews, there is some leeway. Reporting of events “live from the scene.” There is none. Do not stage those.

Sliding Sound, Altered Images

Sliding Sound, Altered Images by Al Tompkins is a good guideline to how journalists should conduct themselves when editing video and audio. Like it was written, the visual has a huge impact on citizens and we as journalists must be careful not to abuse that power.

The list is a good one, and it covers the bases well. It seems like they are common sense rules, but looking at the media it is surprising the number of times stuff appears to be added or mixed around unnecessarily. There has to be a standard and it has to be adhered to. Otherwise how are journalists going to be credible? If we do not have our credibility, we cannot do our jobs. This hurts us, because we will be unable to support ourselves, and this hurts the people of America, because they will lack necessary information.

It's a good list, with good standards. I believe they should be followed.

Monday, March 2, 2009

Staging

The thing that resonated most with me after reading "Staged, Staging, Stages" was the incident Wertheimer described about the TV crew coming and asking the player to recreate his reaction to getting drafted.  Although there are many troubling ethical aspects to this act, I think that the worst part of this is the reputation that it labels journalists with.  I hate to think that a few irresponsible journalists can ruin the perception of all of us.  In movies and television, there seems to be a negative sentiment expressed towards journalists.  We are portrayed as sleazy, and that we don't care about our subjects, we only care about the story.  If this public portrayal is to be reversed, each journalist must be educated in ethics and take it seriously.  Staging shots is one of the most common ethical breaches.  It is  important for each reporter or photographer to not take the easy way out and compromise their ethics.  

Video Editing Ethics Response

The article "Sliding Sound, Altered Images" reminded me of the picture that was altered during the Hezbollah and Israeli 7 Day war. I don't exactly remember what TV Station it was that did it, but I remember that the destruction that was photographed in Lebanon with a night camera was exaggerated and photo-shopped. I remember the TV Station later apologized for the editing and the real photograph was shown.

In certain circumstances I can understand why journalists or news stations may think that editing of original sound bites or film is acceptable. For example, the Las Vegas television station KLAS that was mentioned in the article thought it was appropriate to add in sound to the security camera film. I can understand their ideology in this decision; I think they just wanted the public to understand what happened in more detail so they added sound. I'm sure they didn't mean to indoctrinate the film but they simply just wanted their viewers to be able to feel the intensity of the event with sound.

I never realized how big of an impact special effects or music could make on a story. I just thought that adding music to a story would simply add flavor and make it more interesting to the audience. However, I never realized that it could make it seem as if some things were added into the story that were not in it to begin with. I learned that sounds could make it seem as if things were invented into the story or invoke a feeling that is irrelevant to the goal of the story.

Another thing I learned is that altering photographs can be very dangerous only because you may alter your subject in a way that might be offensive to your audience. I think that minimal editing is the best way to go unless you must edit in order for the picture to be clear.

Discussion of Staging

After reading Dave Wertheimer’s piece on staging, I thought of an experience I had this summer while volunteering at the Olympics. I was standing beside my friend Shao Li, a fellow volunteer from Southern China. We stood in the NIS, waiting for a gymnastics competition to begin. The stands weren’t filled yet and no competitors were on the floor – only us volunteers. A European photographer walked up to my friend and I and asked us to stand under an entry way decorated with the five Olympic rings. Shao Li is a fellow journalism student and he’s fluent in English. We both hesitated and looked at each other. Then the photojournalist pointed to Shao Li and said, “You look more Chinese, how about if you stand right over there?” We both hesitated again and the photographer could tell that we knew something was very wrong with this. He shrugged and said something to the effect of “Oh, never mind then” and walked away.

This experience gave me insight as to why journalists would feel compelled to stage, whether it be with video, photos or audio. I think it’s all related to the pressure the journalist feels within the time frame and circumstance their in. It’s nice to say that the best journalists can be creative no matter what the situation or timing is and that’s true, but it’s also true that we all lose the ability to see and to use our creativity when we’re feeling so pressured. Still, there is no excuse and as journalists we should learn how to deal with such situations where we might feel pressured. We should get used to talking about how we can use situations that aren't obvious in order to produce great work.      

Staging- response from Manu Bhandari

Photographs or videos of events occurring naturally definitely have charms that those of the staged events lack. As a viewer, I had often felt dissatisfied when some video images on television seemed staged, because that ruined the taste of the story. So, I wholeheartedly agree with Dave Wertheimer on the issue of staging and respect him for adhering to his ethics so well.
However, looking from the camerapersons’ point of view, although people like Wertheimer will strongly disagree, one feels staging can sometimes be unavoidable in do-or-die situations for the camerapersons. Because of the competitors’ possession of good images, there is chance of being under intense pressure to get certain types of images or else the camerapersons may have their job positions threatened. There is so much of time pressure and people in the newsroom are waiting for good, certain type of video clips to compete with their competitors’ video clips.
As noted before, staging ruins the taste of a story. I personally believe in that. The only thing I want to pitch for discussion is whether in practical life, with so much time pressure, and pressures from various competitors, the camerapersons can enjoy the freedom to do what Wertheimer has done to remain true to his professional ethics? Also, will it be ethical if we stage the event and mention it to the viewers that we staged the process to explain to them better what had happened, if it can be done?

Video Ethics and Staging -Jennifer Elston

I agree completely with David Wertheimer's article "Staged, Staging, Stages."  Staging of any kind should not be permitted in journalism.  We, as journalists, are there to show the truth and should keep our impact as minimal as possible. Wertheimer suggests using wireless mics and long lenses and then he "tries to be a fly on the wall and just capture it all naturally."  I have to admit that sometimes it is tempting to want to ask a subject to repeat themselves or redo their action, but that is not true.  It is not reality.  When photographers and videographers do this, journalism gets a bad reputation and many viewers start to believe that news is faked for convenience.  The best natural sound, clips, and photographs are actually not staged.   When filming a subject, film at eye level so that the viewers do not get a wrong psychological image from the shot. 
As far as video editing ethics go, editing should be invisible but it should definitely not be used as a way to create bias.  Cuts should not be used to tell anything but the truth.  Editing techniques should be transparent and not as a tool to create bias or to falsify information in any way. 

Staging by Brandon Twichell

Dave Wertheimer's article about staging photographs is very important for journalism today. It surprised me that professional photographers are starting to "trend" in this direction. Have they not taken any photojournalism or journalism ethics classes?
I do not see why photographers are staging in the first place. Is there really nothing else happening that they cannot take pictures of something other than what they want? What happened to creativity and thinking outside the box? I have run into this problem before, where I do not see exactly what I would like to photograph. That's when I get creative and start thinking of other potential photo ideas for my story! It ends up working in my favor every time, too. Staging is completely unnecessary, and I believe that there is always a natural photo for every assignment.

Altered Realities: The truth is not a stage by Jacob Carah

      Al Tompkins and Dave Wertheimer both seem to want the same thing and that is for reporters to document events as they happen, nothing more. Over the weekend I attended The True/False film festival. In light of the framework of some of the films, I considered the issue of visual ethics and the problems with arranging or "staging" events as a fundamental bone of contention for either genre. Wertheimer's argument seems stringent and simple on the surface, he writes, "Our primary obligation is to seek truth and report it as fully as possible, not to manipulate it or to create the news." The take home message here I think is: Don't Do It. 

      Wertheimer's statement is obviously fundamental and in keeping to the NPPA's code of ethics. Yet, Tompkins takes a further step in observing editing standards with the ubiquitous role of video and audio augmentation technology in newsrooms. Out of the five ideas I thought that #1 (Do Not Add) is the most important and in my opinion should act not just as a working guideline but a statute to buffer bad journalism. Its one thing to have a re-creation of an event to better illustrate and communicate past incidents, but be sure to let the audience know why your doing it. When an event is staged and the reporter that tapes the act presents the footage as what really happened it is no longer news but deception. 

     This concept goes for sound as well as images, altering or adding elements whether for emotive or conceptual direction is a thin flimsy line and should be navigated with precision or avoided at all costs. Either way, by manipulating the means in which the audience interprets the story is not journalism, it is just another falsehood that gives journalists a bad reputation and erodes the foundations of the fourth estate. 

Video ethics- chris vlahos

As a broadcast journalist there are times when I am covering a story and nothing seems to go the way I would like it to. First people won't hold still if I want to get a shot of them, or a particular person I want to interview won't say anything that I can use as a soundbite. When this situation occurs it can be tempting to try and stage a scenario in order to get my story done, but it is unethical. Even though it may not be obvious to someone that watches the story, I will always know I cheated myself and the story. I have found that most of the time the best sound bites are spontaneous and come naturally from the speaker, rather than a coached response.

Staging also occurs in radio and print stories as well, but is harder to notice. While it is most obvious when a shot or an interview has been staged in television reporting, staging in general is unethical and ironically produces worse stories than spontaneous one's.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Adderall story

I thought this was a very good radio story with interviews from experts, users, campus police's take on the issue, and even an Adderall dealer. I find it very impressive that they were able to get all of these interviews, especially the users and dealer, since they were endangering themselves by openly discussing the issue. Very well put together story that depicted the Adderall consumption on this campus very accurately. I know many, many people that take Adderall and it is fairly easy to get a perscription or to find someone with one. I was diagnosed with ADD when I was a kid, as many others were, and I'm pretty sure I could get a perscription if I really wanted one. I know people who hate the stuff and people who swear by it as a kind of miracle study drug. I was pretty surprised when I heard the officer say that kids cought with Adderall could be expelled from the campus. I guess since so many people use it, they are really cracking down on Adderall consumption.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Adderall

I was amazed at the way that the problem was presented. Perhaps things have changed since I completed my undergraduate degree. Back in 2006, lots of students were using Adderall to study. The majority were using it illegally. It was one of those things where you could find someone to get it for you if you wanted. Strangely, because I’m slightly ADD, I received requests several times during my time at MIZZOU.

The story presentation was interesting. There was little natural sound, yet what was in there worked. I was clear on who was speaking. I didn’t hear anyone say “you just heard from.” The story appeared to meet all the requirements of a good story. It was also LONG. I’d have liked it better if it was 30 seconds shorter. Good job.

Adderall

I think that this reporting has a good intro saying different way of awaking sleep. It is no doubt that there is a great interview of both sides of effects of Adderall. Reporting both sides seems to be typical in the news reporting. However, it is a good way of depicting what audiences should have to know about Adderall. The approach of this reporting is interesting because it depends on the idea of the existing information and the interviews, not his advices or lecturing to audience. I believe that this is a good way of getting attention from audiences.

Mario Manzini. Whoa.

I thought this piece struck a good balance between the narrator's voice and the subject's voice. At first, although the narration was fun and punchy, I kind of wanted to hear the subject already. But then when I heard Mario, I thought, well I know why this guy's in here sparingly: he talks so fast and with so much energy and detail, that too much of him would be kind of overwhelming. I think the narration was able to control the piece in a way that Mario's voice wouldn't have been able to.
---Tara Cavanaugh

Neuticles response

This audio news piece was really interesting to me because I have heard about Neuticles in the past before but I never really knew what it was. This audio piece informed me on what the product was and then gave provided the views of people that are for Neuticles and against it. I think that the audio piece could have essentially given a little more detail onto the procedure, and what benefit they think it brings to the dog perhaps. Healing information and possible side effects should have been listed as well since it is an operation after all.

I thought it was interesting to know that majority of the people who purchase Neuticles for their dogs are males who have masculinity issues and don’t want their dogs walking around without testicles. It was quite intriguing to see that not many female owners thought it was necessary to get this procedure done. I also liked how a local doctor from Columbia mentioned that she didn’t think it made a difference to the dog if they had artificial testicles implanted or not. She explained that once those hormones were removed from the canine's body they no longer acted like a canine with hormones.

So essentially this procedure seems to only benefit the owners of the dogs or other animals that this procedure is offered to. I think that its pretty pathetic that owners need their pets to have testicles in order to feel comfortable with their masculinity to be able to take their pet on a walk or etc.

Monday, February 23, 2009

KBIA post

Kelsey Waananen

I found the radio story about Neuticles to be rather similar to a cold read. The story was organized well and the information was interesting but there was nothing included that I couldn’t have gotten from simply reading. The only natural sound included was the sound of a dog barking and while this is a nice start, it really doesn’t add anything to the story. The journalist would have been more successful turning it into a TV piece… or even a text piece. There’s no audio to be gathered but at least if there were pictures of video the audience would have been able to orient themselves with where the man does operations and perhaps what the Neuticles look like. Essentially, what this journalist made was a creepy bedtime story.

Neuticles

This was an interesting story, and for the most part very well done. I think that the explanation of what neuticles actually are was sped through perhaps a little too quickly as I found myself going back to get a clear idea of what they are. That could, perhaps, have been done a little better.

The set up is good, going straight for the issue, which is neutering and the problems that pet owners have with it. It then goes to the focus of the story, which addresses that problem. It gives a variety of different opinions and sources, which makes it good reporting.

The way it was told was also well done. It keeps the interest and is remarkably tactful, avoiding any of the obvious kinds of jokes that could have arisen from the mention of testicles. It was very professional.

Mario Manzini

I listened to KBIA’s piece on Mario Manzini and enjoyed this story for the narrator’s direct and clean speaking voice and for the way he structured telling the story of a man who spent his life as an escape artist, and in doing so, escaped a way of life. Manzini’s life story is a successful one and in just a few minutes, the narrator successfully makes Manzini’s context clear with just brief use of quotes and sentences that keep us engaged in Manzini’s story and why he is attracted to what he does for a living. It’s a surprise, as the piece comes to a close, when we learn that he doesn’t even like the feeling of constraint. To be able to explore who Manzini is and what his life motives have been and continue to be, is a tough challenge to tackle in just a few minutes. When this piece finished, I couldn’t think of anything else I wanted to know. The narrator here had it all covered. 

Adderal story response - Manu

The way Justin begins the story is nice. It is in line with the subject matter of the story. He has a good script too. I also like the way he adds a touch of humor to the story and gives a practical reason for what is happening. Instead of making the story traditional, boring educational type, the journalist tries to focus on the practical side, what is the actual reason behind the popularity of Adderal among the college students. Without lecturing, he highlights the misuse of the drug by the students. However, there is a thin line between reporting in such a way and indirectly promoting such a use. A journalist needs to be aware of such matters whenever reporting on such sensitive issues.
In the story, it is also interesting how the journalist found so many sources. He also includes some numbers,but does not burden the listener. The length of the Adderal story is 7 minutes, which is quite a long time for a radio story, but Justin keeps our attention to the story giving us different perspectives and some interesting information from the users. It definitely is not easy to make a long radio story!

Chris Vlahos Blog entry

KBIA Story Blog Entry

I listened to “Missouri Senate Approves Vaporizer Ban”. The story contained good factual reporting but lacked a few crucial characteristics that make good radio stories. First of all it lacked natural sound. The reporter was explaining new legislation that went into place, but she may have been able to go to a local bar or restaurant, if she wasn’t old enough to get into a bar, and get sounds of the bartender and local patrons. The next thing that bothered me about the story was that the reporter took too long to get to the sound bite. I felt like she took more time than necessary trying to introduce the clip to the audience when in essence she could have said a lot less to preface the quote.

KBIA Post - J.T. Burns

I thought the Adderall story was interesting.  I feel like this was a beefed up version of our 2 minute clip assignment.  The reporter did a very good job of getting a variety of interviews that showed multiple perspectives on this story.  It would have been easy to just focus on the student's perspective, but the reporter truly got all sides to this.  Also, I thought it was interesting to see that there were anonymous sources in this story.  That tells us that the reporter must have worked hard to get these interviews.  I also felt like I learned important information from this piece.  As a college student, I have heard of Adderall, but I didn't know many facts about it.  This piece provided that.

KBIA Adderall Story by Brandon Twichell

I found the Adderall story to be the most compelling. It is a great example of radio journalism with its many interviews, notes, and its proximity. It brings to light a problem that most students might not know about since most of the drug-swapping is done in private. The reporter obviously had to do some digging in order to find an illegal user, so this is also a great example of investigative journalism.
The one thing that worked really well with this story that might not have worked so well with print or television journalism is the use of anonymous sources. Since a couple of the sources agreed to allow their voices to be used for the interview while keeping their identities unknown, the audience is better  able to trust the sources. Had the sources been used for a print piece, or had the interviewers agreed to be in silhouette for a television interview, the audience (and editor, for that matter) may have been skeptical of the sources' validity.   Radio journalism is probably the best--and only--way to use anonymous sources.

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Prosthetic Balls to the Walls, Neuticles is a Rock Solid Piece(s) You Won't Miss by Jake Carah

I love a well executed, deadpan-novelty-story in any mode of journalism be it print, broadcast or radio. I thought the Neuticles spot seemed to (forgive me) neuter the competition, in the selection of examples we had to choose from. The fact that these prosthetic canine testicles came to market by a man from Missouri speaks volumes about the state we're in, as well as what people will buy for there pets. In considering the narrative and sound bytes presented by the reporter the story is a veritable tongue-and-cheek kick to the..."cadillac of prosthetic dog testicles."

 Upon a review of the story the humor can seem a tad campy, yet I feel it is the novelty of the product and that it is a story for radio that makes it work. If it had been told in any other medium lets say with pictures this story would have dropped like the proverbial. . . eh, you get the picture.  And that is the point. Listening and imagining the aspects of this story idea, while a bit puerile, uncouth or perhaps even gross in actuality, the satire and delivery mode make it clever and funny.  Besides, I think that is the point of convergence, it is finding the mode or medium in which to tell a story the best way and as for neuticles I don't believe I would have like to have heard it any other way.

KBIA Post - Jennifer Elston

The KBIA story on Adderall was my favorite of the three stories posted to the spring schedule for this course.  The beginning sounded very professional, grabbed my attention, and set a good tone for the piece.  Overall, the editing was very smooth, with only minor scratchiness.  This story is very relevant to our school.  I know many people who have taken their Adderall to help with finals or huge essays.  The narrator had a good variety of sources, used a conversational, yet refined tone, and used the subject-verb-object format that sounds best on the radio.  I feel that this piece was very well thought out.  It seems as if he had a strict script which he abided to had good numbers and outside information and facts.  The Adderall piece had less natural sound than the Neuticles piece, but I was drawn to the piece on medication, probably because it is so relatable.  The Neuticles piece felt like a story that the people who made the product had recorded, while the Adderall piece was more directed at raising awareness.