Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Good/Bad design blog for Nov. 6
Headlines shouldn't be disguised as buttons and vice versa. Headlines should be kept close to their associated text so that people aren't confused about what is connected and what isn't.
Having said that, I disagree with their assertion that Web sites shouldn't include sections that say things like, "This page is best viewed with Internet Explorer 6." This is particularly offensive to me because we're in the news business. It's not our job to hide things from readers. If a Web page would best be viewed in a particular browser, or if a video can only be seen in a particular format (such as Windows Media Player, QuickTime player, etc.), it is not only a good idea but imperative to tell readers about this. Otherwise, you'll lose people very quickly, which means less traffic to your Web site and, in the long run, fewer advertising dollars.
Having said that, the best approach would be to design a Web site in a way that can be viewed across a wide variety of browsers without problems that could be easily fixed. It's a good idea to test a site on several browsers.
I learned that you should align all elements in relatively the same way — all left, all centered and so forth. It's a great idea, simple and effective, and I hadn't really considered how this element could play such an important role before reading these.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
writing for a visual medium
visual medium writing
Another imperative aspect of writing for the visual medium is organizing the shot sequence for the journalistic piece. Shot sequence determines what story the viewer sees and interprets as news. There are many ideal shot sequences. All of these sequences feature the importance of B roll. B roll is crucial because these cutaways are excellent transitions in between clips. They also provide context to the story. In sports stories they are used as a to break between highlights in the package. This allows the viewer to digest the highlights they just saw. It also prevents the viewers from being bombarded with information. B roll shots should be five seconds long and still add to the story, as opposed to distracting viewers from the real issue.
Writing for a video package is very similar to writing for an audio package. The good journalist wants to provide great sound bites and information. They also want the story to be told by the people for the people. The reporter should only put the story in context.
Writing a good video package is composed of focusing on the shot sequence. storyboarding the filming, good B roll, and letting the interview subjects tell the story.
writing for a visual medium
Anyway. There are a lot of things that writing for a visual medium has in common with writing for print, but there are also a lot of key differences. Most of these are structural; when writing for a visual medium, you have to concentrate on making the entire piece engaging, but you don't necessarily have to have the most important fact first. You don't have to follow inverted pyramid structure all the time, as you should with print news stories. A person is more likely to watch an entire 1:30 news package than they are to read a really long story with lots of information, so you can rest assured they'll probably watch the whole thing and you don't have to make the ending/conclusion the least important. However, since you have less time than space to cover your issue, every soundbite, standup and piece of natural sound should have a purpose. And because its a visual medium, every picture should be carefully thought out; every piece of video should be shot for a reason, and should not only add to a story but, really, construct it. It's most important to keep in mind that you're doing the story visually for a reason; do what you couldn't do through just a print story.
Writing for a Visual Medium
When writing for a visual medium, it is important to always think about what images you are going to use to match your words. The images take precedence in a visual medium and the words are just there to add clarification or to back those images up. It is important to be concise in your writing since the focus is on the images. People will all too easily zone out if narration and sound bites go on for too long. Language should grab attention and be easy to understand and the images must relate to what the reporter is saying.
Shook gives a blueprint of what your package should look like. He says that it is first important to find the focus of your story. From there you can write your studio lead-in and the package lead. At first I was confused about the difference between the lead-in and the lead. I know that the studio needs a lead-in before the package starts, but I believe that you need to be careful so that your studio lead-in and package lead are not too repetitive. They should both convey the central thought of the story, but they also need to be distinct from one another. This part of writing the package seems like a great challenge.
Integrating dueling elements
Obviously writing for the video will be different. You are limited to the context of the footage you were able to capture and to the time frame of the piece. But the readings give guidelines that mimic the structure of most any guide to writing straight news. Tailoring the video to the story is the challenge I think. It requires intense editing and constant reflection and therefore revision.
Apparently the focus statement is among the most important tasks to achieve in a visual story. It ties in all of the elements and directs the viewer's attention to what will be going on so they can funnel what they see and hear into one coherent concept.
Writing For a Visual Medium
Writing for a Visual Medium
Break Down the Process - Tomeka Weatherspoon
Writing for a Visual Medium – Precisely Concise
The most important thing in visual media is obviously its asset to be able to tell a story. Thus, I believe that writing for a visual medium should be able to focus on the story, basically in the same principle as writing on paper as a reporter. However, unlike writing on paper and guiding people through a story with your mighty pen from the very beginning, I think writing for a visual medium has more to do with getting all the pieces of the puzzle together. By puzzle pieces I mean we as convergence reporters have more tools in our hands to actually “plan” the focus or attention emphasis of readers (viewers). To elaborate, think of a reporter who has a camera or a video camera. This reporter, after getting the footage or photo, has to decide how to use and match this media information with whatever he/she is going to write. Now, I guess that’s how we have been working so far as students of a fundamentals class. Get your media first, and then think about how to make it all work together by editing them. However, I think as skilled convergence reporters, I think we will have a better sense of how to tell the story, and with that blueprint be able to handle all our tools of storytelling to make fit the pieces we need. I believe that the writing part will act as one of the vital pieces of the story, the only catch being it must always be as concise as possible.
I have been writing some kind of piece all my life, whether it is a paper for classes, an essay for the school paper, diaries, letters, you name it. But I have always found myself writing a bit longer than I had hoped to (just like in this blog entry). I think my convergence training and experiences will definitely give me a good lesson in not rambling on and on about a story. I think conciseness and precisely getting to the point is very important in writing for a visual medium, since you are trying to ‘aid’ people who can already ‘see’ parts of your puzzle pieces, like I mentioned earlier. That I would definitely like to get better at.
Monday, October 20, 2008
Making words match your medium
Harder than it looks - Kate Chizek
In the Poynter article, Al Tompkins states that journalists should, "Connect your eye, your heart and body to journalism." Journalists have to be passionate and willing to go the extra step. Finding the perfect words may be hard, but they have to dig to nail a story. I like how Poynter discusses focusing within a "story-in-a-sentence." I think this is wise - if you can't sum up your story in one sentence, your readers will be confused. If there is too much going on with the visual aspects and the copy, no one will be able to follow the story nor will they care.
In our use of natural sound, the reading from Chapter 9 says you must use it "liberally" because it helps establish the news environment. After the NPR radio story, I know I personally have to remember that the natural sound really must fit the story. If I use it just to have natural sound, it may confuse readers. In the visual medium, this natural sound can also be captured with images, making the viewer feel as if he or she is there. Obviously, more thought is necessary for the visual medium than I originally thought!
Thinking Critically
A multimedia journalist must critically analyze what needs to be in the story, and shorten it into a sentence. We must keep a very narrow focus to our stories, or else run the risk of having a forty minute video. It's easy for us a visual storytellers to get distracted with some of the visual schematics of our job. I think to solve my problem I will more closely scrutinize my stories and go in to a story having done more research.
It's important for us to know what angle we're going for. Again, and I've found this throughout my time in this class so far, journalism is very mental. Once we really know what the stories needs, we can better plan for what we will get. I think by reading these articles, I will know how to better manage my time in videos without abandoning sound videographic principles.
Coherency
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Nate Birt - Writing for Visual Mediums - for Oct. 21
According to the piece titled "Writing the Package," it's important to carefully fuse voiceover content with the actually visual content of the video. If you're talking about people eating chili at a fundraising event, for example, you wouldn't want to show the outside of the building at that time. Instead, you'd want to show the people eating their chili and having a (fun/enjoyable/fill-in-your-choice-of-adjective) time.
I didn't know that so much advanced planning went into a TV news story, though I suppose it's only natural. Even for a breaking news story, this chapter notes, reporters can take the time to get to understand the story and frame it appropriately.
I plan to use the idea of building a script for my piece and writing out the script. It seems like it will be rather difficult to time things — for example, how long it takes to do a particular voiceover and then transition into interview footage, B-roll and so on, but I'm sure that after a few rounds of practice (something we discussed in class), it will go more naturally. I'm also wondering how we will insert a voiceover into our videos, but it's something we'll probably be learning about soon.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Sportscenter minute
The Sportscenter minute has an advantage that a written story does not. While a written story only satisfies the visual sense, a video package satisfies both the visual and audio senses. By satisfying more of the basic human senses, the online video package provides a more enjoyable experience to the webpage’s visitors. It also relieves them of the strain of having to read a story.
By providing a brief synopsis of the occurrences in the world of sports, it allows them to know the important facts immediately, without having to spend 10 minutes reading a story. ESPN also provides a story online, if visitors want more information on a particular topic/issue.
I found out that Adam “Pac-man” Jones had once again been suspended indefinitely by the NFL and heard expert opinion on the issue, within one minute of visiting the site. These results are amazing. The internet is truly the best way to find information fast. That is the reason why I am in convergence because it provides information quicker than any other medium.
The Sportscenter minute is a top notch web video that provides information quickly and satisfies more of the five basic senses than a written story. This is the reason why the internet is the top destination for news, and sports highlights.
Chicago may get 'gay-friendly' high school
I watched this story having no idea about whether or not there would be good visual representations, really. I figured that since it was an issue story, it could go either way and it could be difficult to capture appropriate B-roll since the school hadn't already been constructed. I wasn't really surprised to see that the visuals were limited to graphics and to some sporadic B-roll of school-age students and classroom activities, but I was a little disappointed at how visually uninteresting it was. They could have had more footage of students meeting or doing activities as part of a school's GSA, or something, really.
In this case, there was a text version of the story, and though I feel like video can do more to attract the senses and tell stories sometimes, this was not one of those times. The text and a few still photos really told the story better.
In both cases, though, the story was good— but it wasn't meant for a video.
Maher accused of trickery
Asian Stocks Rally
http://www.cnn.com/video/?iref=videoglobal
In this video, a CNN correspondent in Hong Kong outlines the unprecedented nature of a global economic bailout. The coverage however mainly focused on the market reaction to the economic stimulus plans proposed by G7 governments. The visuals were relevant to the story, but were mundane, cliche and boring. Most of the shots were simply of stock tickers which tell us very little in scope and only repeat the information that the stock market was doing better on the news. There was also some footgae of the NYSE floor, but it was so generic that it might as well have been stock footage.
A little bit of ticker is fine, but I owuld prefer to see something that reveals a little more information. I would have included clips on government meetings and federal reserve shots. Also, the transitions in video were a little odd. The story was about the Asian stocks rallying last night, but occassionally they would include a shot of the NYSE without a clear enough segway. CNN needs to assume the viewer knows nothing about the markets and should explain or imply what they are seeing on the screen.
If the story were written in plain text, it would read fairly choppy. The reporter used a lot of "Well, And, So" transitions that makes sense in speech, but not on paper. The pauses that exist in the audi/video format are necessary, but those who read it straight through in print may find thatwithout the necessary pause, the story is choppy. Obviously written stories and audio stories are two different animals.
It always seems better to be able to ‘watch’ sports news
Website URL : http://news.naver.com/vod/vod.nhn?office_id=214&article_id=0000082974§ion_id=107
This video (a clip from the nine o’clock NewsDesk, an evening news program by one of Korea’s largest nationwide networks MBC (Munhwa Broadcasting Company), is titled “The Olympic Heroes Do it Again.” The news story (1:43) is about Korea’s National Athletic Games which is going on right now and Korean olympians who won medals in the Beijing games participating in it. The medalists, including Park Taehwan (swimming) and Jang Miran (weightlifting) were victorious in the domestic games, overcoming their rivals by huge margins.
I think one thing this video story lacks is coverage on some other Olympians who faced strong opponents that struggled. It looked almost as if it was a PR video, one that advertises the two Olympic medalists. There are such athletes who triumphed in the Beijing games but were on the wrong end of an upset from other talented domestic competition. Perhaps this could be whole another story, but for some people who are only able to catch this news video, it might have been more diverse to add about 20 seconds and add that aspect to the story.
If this story was a “text-only story,” I think it might not even have caught the attention of may news spectators, especially because it’s about sports. One great thing about visual coverage of sports is that it is always more exciting and gives you a sense of actually being there. Also, through video and familiar scenes (for example, Park swimming past the leader to finish first) reminiscence of these figures and their accomplishments could be duplicated, thus making it a story with more impact. I think that’s why we have more analysis and projections in the text version of a sports story.
Monday, October 13, 2008
Video Example Critique
"The Milkman"
http://videos.stltoday.com/p/video?id=2279691
This story discusses a male "lactation" counselor at a children's store in St. Louis. While a text narrative could have given us more information about the store and Eric Nemens, the counselor, it would have lost the visual effect of babies being fed by their mothers; with bright eyes and happy faces, it's easier to understand what Nemens is discussing about the bond with a baby. The reporter timed Nemens' questions perfectly about being a father - she added ambience noise of babies cooing and crying, as well as excerpts from Howie Day's song, Collide. It gives a strong visual about the bond between a parent and a newborn.
I wish the reporter would have covered more about the irony of having a male as a "lactation" counselor; this appears to be unique, so how do the mothers feel asking him for advice? Where is their voice within this story? It becomes very one-sided. While we learn about why Nemens enjoys working with children, we completely lose the aspect of the unique situation. I think more interviews would be needed. While these interviews may be in a text form of the story, at least some short clip would have been beneficial.
Additionally, it would be nice to see some interactions between Nemens and the new mothers. As viewers, we can see the mothers conversing with one another, but that isn't what the story is about. We need to see a better visual of Nemens, and I think that would lead to a better overall understanding.
I like the way newspaper websites are trying to stay up-to-date with our modern age. With opportunities for readers to visually see their stories, newspaper corporations can stay alive in our fast paced world!!
Pay It Forward
Video Example Critique - Tomeka Weatherspoon
Journalistic Video
The visuals in the story are absolutely stunning. Helicopter shots set the scene around the mountain and a videographer clearly rode in a hang-glider as well to capture some amazing footage. None of the shots lasted for longer than 5 seconds, which kept the audience interested and engage.
The narrator was simple and clearly and concisely told the story in an effective way. I would, however, liked to hear some more original voices in the story. This was meant to be a quick and painless story, and I understand that, but why couldn't the network interviewed at least one person. They had video of the person, so I think a sound bite should have been included. Original voices bring an authenticity to the story I feel is lacking thus far. I would have liked to know the outcome of the flight also. The scene was wonderfully set, but then not really explored through to completion.
I quite enjoyed this brief story, but clearly there is room for improvement.
The link to the video story: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/27163150#%2327163150