Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Good/Bad design blog for Nov. 6

Williams and Tollett's two chapters on good and bad Web design point out an important truth: Communication, not just beautification, is key to good Web design.
Headlines shouldn't be disguised as buttons and vice versa. Headlines should be kept close to their associated text so that people aren't confused about what is connected and what isn't.
Having said that, I disagree with their assertion that Web sites shouldn't include sections that say things like, "This page is best viewed with Internet Explorer 6." This is particularly offensive to me because we're in the news business. It's not our job to hide things from readers. If a Web page would best be viewed in a particular browser, or if a video can only be seen in a particular format (such as Windows Media Player, QuickTime player, etc.), it is not only a good idea but imperative to tell readers about this. Otherwise, you'll lose people very quickly, which means less traffic to your Web site and, in the long run, fewer advertising dollars.
Having said that, the best approach would be to design a Web site in a way that can be viewed across a wide variety of browsers without problems that could be easily fixed. It's a good idea to test a site on several browsers.
I learned that you should align all elements in relatively the same way — all left, all centered and so forth. It's a great idea, simple and effective, and I hadn't really considered how this element could play such an important role before reading these.

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

writing for a visual medium

Shook's "Writing the Package," was very helpful in explaining the breakdown of how to write, capture, and prepare for a visual story.  It is important to think of every little detail.  The process might have to be rushed sometimes depending on the story and your job, but if you miss detail it could lead to a poor story.  I like how he explained hte studio lead-in--it shouldn't be an intro to the story about to come, it should be instant intrusive, a dive right into the story.  Afterall, you aren't given much time to tell the story, so you must make hte most of it.
Also, "visual proof" is essential to the story as a whole.  This story relies on the visual, with words to explain and back up what the audience is seeing. The end is especially important.  It should be a visual, if possible, one that you picked out at the beginning when you arrived on scene and that you are working toward as an ending goal.  It should be an obvious end to the story.

Finally, I know I need to work on my planning before I hit the scene.  Shook talks about how you should have a storyboard or ideas about the way the story will be organized, but should always be prepared to have your organizational method or your ideas change on the scene.  Having an idea set in stone before you arrive on scene can lead to laziness.

visual medium writing

When writing for the visual medium it is important to be as detailed as possible. Detailing storyboards before filming is crucial because it mentally prepares the cameraman/camerawoman for the task ahead. It provides the cameraperson with an idea of the types of shots they are going to film and idea of what they will be filming.
Another imperative aspect of writing for the visual medium is organizing the shot sequence for the journalistic piece. Shot sequence determines what story the viewer sees and interprets as news. There are many ideal shot sequences. All of these sequences feature the importance of B roll. B roll is crucial because these cutaways are excellent transitions in between clips. They also provide context to the story. In sports stories they are used as a to break between highlights in the package. This allows the viewer to digest the highlights they just saw. It also prevents the viewers from being bombarded with information. B roll shots should be five seconds long and still add to the story, as opposed to distracting viewers from the real issue.
Writing for a video package is very similar to writing for an audio package. The good journalist wants to provide great sound bites and information. They also want the story to be told by the people for the people. The reporter should only put the story in context.
Writing a good video package is composed of focusing on the shot sequence. storyboarding the filming, good B roll, and letting the interview subjects tell the story.

writing for a visual medium

The readings concerning writing for a visual medium primarily focused on, well, finding a focus. This makes sense, and it's a common theme among writing for all mediums. In the past, most of my experience has been in news writing; I've written a lot of news/arts/etc stories, and the semester I write editorials. And in every one of these writing situations, I've had to find a focus; if you can't come up with one sentence to effectively summarize the point that you're trying to make or the intent you're pursuing with a story, you may need to rethink about whether the story makes sense.
Anyway. There are a lot of things that writing for a visual medium has in common with writing for print, but there are also a lot of key differences. Most of these are structural; when writing for a visual medium, you have to concentrate on making the entire piece engaging, but you don't necessarily have to have the most important fact first. You don't have to follow inverted pyramid structure all the time, as you should with print news stories. A person is more likely to watch an entire 1:30 news package than they are to read a really long story with lots of information, so you can rest assured they'll probably watch the whole thing and you don't have to make the ending/conclusion the least important. However, since you have less time than space to cover your issue, every soundbite, standup and piece of natural sound should have a purpose. And because its a visual medium, every picture should be carefully thought out; every piece of video should be shot for a reason, and should not only add to a story but, really, construct it. It's most important to keep in mind that you're doing the story visually for a reason; do what you couldn't do through just a print story.

Writing for a Visual Medium

When writing for a visual medium, it is important to always think about what images you are going to use to match your words.  The images take precedence in a visual medium and the words are just there to add clarification or to back those images up.  It is important to be concise in your writing since the focus is on the images. People will all too easily zone out if narration and sound bites go on for too long. Language should grab attention and be easy to understand and the images must relate to what the reporter is saying.

Shook gives a blueprint of what your package should look like.  He says that it is first important to find the focus of your story.  From there you can write your studio lead-in and the package lead. At first I was confused about the difference between the lead-in and the lead. I know that the studio needs a lead-in before the package starts, but I believe that you need to be careful so that your studio lead-in and package lead are not too repetitive. They should both convey the central thought of the story, but they also need to be distinct from one another. This part of writing the package seems like a great challenge.   

Integrating dueling elements

Writing for video is essentially an art of combining two mediums. I like to think of the video element as a supplement to the writing because the story still depends on the reporter's lead, transitions, and contextual setup. The sound bytes replace the quotes of a story, which aren't the reporter's creation anyway. So video to me is supplemental to the traditional way of storytelling, not a new way.

Obviously writing for the video will be different. You are limited to the context of the footage you were able to capture and to the time frame of the piece. But the readings give guidelines that mimic the structure of most any guide to writing straight news. Tailoring the video to the story is the challenge I think. It requires intense editing and constant reflection and therefore revision.

Apparently the focus statement is among the most important tasks to achieve in a visual story. It ties in all of the elements and directs the viewer's attention to what will be going on so they can funnel what they see and hear into one coherent concept.

Writing For a Visual Medium


Before taking this class, I thought writing for a visual news story would be a lot easier. I thought since you could see what was happening right before your eyes, that what needs to be said would be obvious. Editing our 30 second clips made me realize that this isn't really the case. Although we didn't have to add voice overs or really write a lot of it on our own, I could tell that adding the voice overs and writing for it wouldn't be as easy as I had imagined. 
For a visual news story, the interviews, b-roll and reporter narration all have to tie together in a way that is clear and meaningful. All of this, along with editing the video clips and making everything follow an order that makes sense can be very challenging. The reporter has almost no control over what sources say in the interview, so until you get their answers to your questions, you can't begin to write in the other parts. When it comes to b-roll, you probably don't want to describe exactly what is going on (because that's obvious if the viewer can see it) but it can be difficult to find something truthful and relevent to say during those clips. Overall, I've realized that writing for a visual story isn't obvious and that there are several things to remember before you start. 

Writing for a Visual Medium

When I first started writing for the different aspects of media on my webpage, I thought it would be the same as writing for print. You sit down, tell the story in a succinct yet informative manner and send it off to be published or printed or whatever you're doing with it. This is not the case at all. Writing for a visual medium requires a reporter to be slightly more creative. You have to be able to make your readers want to view or listen to the story you're trying to tell without giving it completely away, and you don't have much space to grab their attention in. When they're actually viewing your story, you have to know just how much to tell them and just how much to show them without overwhelming them with information, and how to make the different aspects of your story balance so the viewer doesn't feel they're getting all reporter and no interview or vice versa. You still have to be able to get your point across in a succint and informative manner, but you have to remember there are other mediums telling your story besides writing, so it has to be decided what needs to be written out and said and what can be shown. You don't want to make your viewer feel stupid, like you as a journalist are spelling everything out for them, yet you want to make sure you're doing your job and getting the story told. It's a narrow line to walk, and one that's taking me personally lots of practice and experience to figure out the best way to handle different stories.

Break Down the Process - Tomeka Weatherspoon

The readings were especially helpful, in terms of organization and technique when creating video stories. As a viewer, I didn't think to pick a part a video story to see its framework. The process is a lot more complex than it appears. Part of the point is to make the story appear seamless. The viewer shouldn't be able to see the process, just experience the story.

Creating them still a form of storytelling, but they sometimes get a bad reputation for being overly simplified and fragmented. Those are the ones that have not been planned sufficiently. They did not break down the process and give appropriate appreciation for individual components, such as sound. This is one of the benefits of having developmental stages. It gives you a chance to focus your attention. 

Writing for a Visual Medium – Precisely Concise

As I read the different reading materials for class, I couldn’t help but journey back to that moment a couple of weeks ago when I was sitting in front of a computer in the Futures Lab, thinking over how I was going to edit my captured video clips. We weren’t supposed to have any words or captions, but probably as everyone else, I was sort of making ‘unseen’ scripts of my own just to get a glimpse of how my short piece of video would turn out.

The most important thing in visual media is obviously its asset to be able to tell a story. Thus, I believe that writing for a visual medium should be able to focus on the story, basically in the same principle as writing on paper as a reporter. However, unlike writing on paper and guiding people through a story with your mighty pen from the very beginning, I think writing for a visual medium has more to do with getting all the pieces of the puzzle together. By puzzle pieces I mean we as convergence reporters have more tools in our hands to actually “plan” the focus or attention emphasis of readers (viewers). To elaborate, think of a reporter who has a camera or a video camera. This reporter, after getting the footage or photo, has to decide how to use and match this media information with whatever he/she is going to write. Now, I guess that’s how we have been working so far as students of a fundamentals class. Get your media first, and then think about how to make it all work together by editing them. However, I think as skilled convergence reporters, I think we will have a better sense of how to tell the story, and with that blueprint be able to handle all our tools of storytelling to make fit the pieces we need. I believe that the writing part will act as one of the vital pieces of the story, the only catch being it must always be as concise as possible.


I have been writing some kind of piece all my life, whether it is a paper for classes, an essay for the school paper, diaries, letters, you name it. But I have always found myself writing a bit longer than I had hoped to (just like in this blog entry). I think my convergence training and experiences will definitely give me a good lesson in not rambling on and on about a story. I think conciseness and precisely getting to the point is very important in writing for a visual medium, since you are trying to ‘aid’ people who can already ‘see’ parts of your puzzle pieces, like I mentioned earlier. That I would definitely like to get better at.

Monday, October 20, 2008

Making words match your medium

       Writing is essential to great journalism; it's the foundation, the bigger picture, and the main thing that brings a story to life for a reader.  I've always known that writing is the most important thing for papers, but I believe my experience here at MU's J-School has really shown me that writing is important for all types of journalism, including the newest member to the J-family, convergence.
       My main reason for switching to convergence this summer was to gain some extra skills to make myself more marketable as a broadcast journalist upon graduation.  I thought there would be more Internet training and maybe some more use of more different types of equipment.  While we haven't focused heavily on the writing for these different mediums, the examples we've seen in class and our own stories have used more writing than I first assumed.  
       One of the main things I've taken away from this class thus far is that writing for these different journalism mediums is that writing includes so much more than actual words on a paper.  Writing for a story with pictures means taking a scene setter shot, a profile shot, and a close shot to paint a full story.  Writing for an audio story means incorporating natural sound, interesting sound bites, and your own observations to describe a story with only sounds.  As we focus more on our video stories, I am looking forward to the way our pictures, B-roll, and voice overs will help take our viewers to the story.  
     The bottom line is that writing is very important for visual mediums, but that the writing in this sense includes more than just printed words.  Writing for visual or even audio mediums calls for using pictures, sounds, and your imagination to bring a story to life in a creative and interactive way.

Harder than it looks - Kate Chizek

I am going to be honest; before entering journalism school and interning for a broadcast news medium this summer, I thought writing and reporting for a visual medium was relatively easy. I just assumed that reporters could sit down, pinpoint their story, and write the copy easily; the interviews would be easy to get, and most,if not all, would support the story being told. I have quickly found, especially in 4802, this is not the case. First of all, your sources shouldn't support your story; good reporters go in without pre-notions of what they are looking for. They have questions prepared to ask, but they don't only dig for what falls in the scope of their intended story. They ask questions and see the big picture, withholding all bias they may have had.

In the Poynter article, Al Tompkins states that journalists should, "Connect your eye, your heart and body to journalism." Journalists have to be passionate and willing to go the extra step. Finding the perfect words may be hard, but they have to dig to nail a story. I like how Poynter discusses focusing within a "story-in-a-sentence." I think this is wise - if you can't sum up your story in one sentence, your readers will be confused. If there is too much going on with the visual aspects and the copy, no one will be able to follow the story nor will they care.

In our use of natural sound, the reading from Chapter 9 says you must use it "liberally" because it helps establish the news environment. After the NPR radio story, I know I personally have to remember that the natural sound really must fit the story. If I use it just to have natural sound, it may confuse readers. In the visual medium, this natural sound can also be captured with images, making the viewer feel as if he or she is there. Obviously, more thought is necessary for the visual medium than I originally thought!

Thinking Critically

One of the things I had trouble with for the thirty second video assignment was time. I had so many good ideas and strong footage, but not enough time to include everything I wanted. I thought about it some more and it became a real conundrum. How does a multiplatform journalist respect the alotted time without sacrificing content? After reading the Poynter online article, I found the answer is pretty clear.

A multimedia journalist must critically analyze what needs to be in the story, and shorten it into a sentence. We must keep a very narrow focus to our stories, or else run the risk of having a forty minute video. It's easy for us a visual storytellers to get distracted with some of the visual schematics of our job. I think to solve my problem I will more closely scrutinize my stories and go in to a story having done more research.

It's important for us to know what angle we're going for. Again, and I've found this throughout my time in this class so far, journalism is very mental. Once we really know what the stories needs, we can better plan for what we will get. I think by reading these articles, I will know how to better manage my time in videos without abandoning sound videographic principles.

Coherency

A successful journalist will heed the advice of the Visual Edge in Doug White's piece and "focus" on the topic at hand.  The "Focus" itself is covered in both readings, and is defined as a sentence summary, containing the entire story.  If one cannot summarize his or her story like this, it is said to be too long.  It's this nutshell premise that keeps the story easily digestible for viewers.  For instance, it's key to think about the subject and be sure that all possible nooks and crannies are concisely covered.  Interview subjects in ways that challenge them to be creative and open with responses.   Visuals should match the topic of the speaker whether it's the narrator or the interviewee.  Shoot each shot from different angles and make the information as easy to digest as is humanly possible.

"Writing the Package" by Fred Shook is a guided resource for those looking to take the advice above and apply it in easy ways.  Shook's skeleton proceeds as follows; each journalist should lead with a Focus statement/Studio lead-in that highlights the point of the story and captures the viewer's attention, then he or she should proceed to the package lead in a main idea to communicate and a visual to prove it, from there we move to a body or middle segment which should highlight four ideas that compose the topic, finally we have a final visual, closing sound and voice over to cap the story off.

After reading the articles, I've concluded that the most important thing for a story in a visual medium is cohesion, or the perfect union of words, sound and visuals.  Without context, or visual confirmation, words and ideas puzzle an audience.  Or worse, do not register.  Stories need to be coherent to communicate their topic, as do any other type of non-abstract medium.

Kevin Ornduff

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Nate Birt - Writing for Visual Mediums - for Oct. 21

After reading about writing for a visual medium, I am going to make a concerted effort to introduce and close the story I produce by myself without allowing a source to do it for me.
According to the piece titled "Writing the Package," it's important to carefully fuse voiceover content with the actually visual content of the video. If you're talking about people eating chili at a fundraising event, for example, you wouldn't want to show the outside of the building at that time. Instead, you'd want to show the people eating their chili and having a (fun/enjoyable/fill-in-your-choice-of-adjective) time.
I didn't know that so much advanced planning went into a TV news story, though I suppose it's only natural. Even for a breaking news story, this chapter notes, reporters can take the time to get to understand the story and frame it appropriately.
I plan to use the idea of building a script for my piece and writing out the script. It seems like it will be rather difficult to time things — for example, how long it takes to do a particular voiceover and then transition into interview footage, B-roll and so on, but I'm sure that after a few rounds of practice (something we discussed in class), it will go more naturally. I'm also wondering how we will insert a voiceover into our videos, but it's something we'll probably be learning about soon.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Sportscenter minute

ESPN.com is the leader in sports convergence journalism. The world wide leader in sports is also the world wide leader of sports on the web. The ESPN Sportscenter minute is a staple of the successful website. The Sportscenter minute gives a minute or two briefing of up to the minute sports news, complete with highlights and an anchor reading the news.
The Sportscenter minute has an advantage that a written story does not. While a written story only satisfies the visual sense, a video package satisfies both the visual and audio senses. By satisfying more of the basic human senses, the online video package provides a more enjoyable experience to the webpage’s visitors. It also relieves them of the strain of having to read a story.
By providing a brief synopsis of the occurrences in the world of sports, it allows them to know the important facts immediately, without having to spend 10 minutes reading a story. ESPN also provides a story online, if visitors want more information on a particular topic/issue.
I found out that Adam “Pac-man” Jones had once again been suspended indefinitely by the NFL and heard expert opinion on the issue, within one minute of visiting the site. These results are amazing. The internet is truly the best way to find information fast. That is the reason why I am in convergence because it provides information quicker than any other medium.
The Sportscenter minute is a top notch web video that provides information quickly and satisfies more of the five basic senses than a written story. This is the reason why the internet is the top destination for news, and sports highlights.

Chicago may get 'gay-friendly' high school

http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/10/13/gay.friendly.school/index.html#cnnSTCVideo
I watched this story having no idea about whether or not there would be good visual representations, really. I figured that since it was an issue story, it could go either way and it could be difficult to capture appropriate B-roll since the school hadn't already been constructed. I wasn't really surprised to see that the visuals were limited to graphics and to some sporadic B-roll of school-age students and classroom activities, but I was a little disappointed at how visually uninteresting it was. They could have had more footage of students meeting or doing activities as part of a school's GSA, or something, really.
In this case, there was a text version of the story, and though I feel like video can do more to attract the senses and tell stories sometimes, this was not one of those times. The text and a few still photos really told the story better.
In both cases, though, the story was good— but it wasn't meant for a video.

Maher accused of trickery

http://www.cnn.com/video/#/showbiz

A story on Bill Maher's documentary "Religulous" caught my eye since it has a chance of being nominated for an Academy Award. The story reports on subjects of the film who are now complaining about being tricked by Maher into doing interviews that they did not know were connected to his comedic documentary about religion. The man who directed "Borat" also directed "Religulous" which adds credence to the claim that the subjects were tricked. The video's b-roll consists of clips from the movie, which gives viewers an idea of what Maher's documentary is about so that they can follow along with the news report.

The video quotes one subject, Rev. Jeremiah Cummings, but never shows an actual interview with him. I realize that he may not have wanted to be shown on camera, but since he is such a big source in this story, that interview would have been a good addition. I was also disappointed that the report used what looked like an old interview with Maher and the director where they admit to lying to people to get interviews. However, the report pulls only a soundbite from the pair and I think the piece should have at least included an explanation from them on why they lied to subjects. The piece is very one-sided since we don't directly hear from Maher.

I don't think this story would be that hampered by being "text only." The only benefit of video in this case is that the report can show clips from Maher's documentary. Those clips do give us a better idea about the content of the film, but a few sentences in a print story could also clear that up for us.

Asian Stocks Rally

Zach Wade

http://www.cnn.com/video/?iref=videoglobal

In this video, a CNN correspondent in Hong Kong outlines the unprecedented nature of a global economic bailout. The coverage however mainly focused on the market reaction to the economic stimulus plans proposed by G7 governments. The visuals were relevant to the story, but were mundane, cliche and boring. Most of the shots were simply of stock tickers which tell us very little in scope and only repeat the information that the stock market was doing better on the news. There was also some footgae of the NYSE floor, but it was so generic that it might as well have been stock footage.

A little bit of ticker is fine, but I owuld prefer to see something that reveals a little more information. I would have included clips on government meetings and federal reserve shots. Also, the transitions in video were a little odd. The story was about the Asian stocks rallying last night, but occassionally they would include a shot of the NYSE without a clear enough segway. CNN needs to assume the viewer knows nothing about the markets and should explain or imply what they are seeing on the screen.

If the story were written in plain text, it would read fairly choppy. The reporter used a lot of "Well, And, So" transitions that makes sense in speech, but not on paper. The pauses that exist in the audi/video format are necessary, but those who read it straight through in print may find thatwithout the necessary pause, the story is choppy. Obviously written stories and audio stories are two different animals.

It always seems better to be able to ‘watch’ sports news

For the sake of trying something different, I tried searching Korean websites for journalistic videos. One thing I kept in mind in my search was that the journalistic piece should have some merit for being a video-type one. That is why I chose a sports news piece.

Website URL : http://news.naver.com/vod/vod.nhn?office_id=214&article_id=0000082974&section_id=107

This video (a clip from the nine o’clock NewsDesk, an evening news program by one of Korea’s largest nationwide networks MBC (Munhwa Broadcasting Company), is titled “The Olympic Heroes Do it Again.” The news story (1:43) is about Korea’s National Athletic Games which is going on right now and Korean olympians who won medals in the Beijing games participating in it. The medalists, including Park Taehwan (swimming) and Jang Miran (weightlifting) were victorious in the domestic games, overcoming their rivals by huge margins.

I think one thing this video story lacks is coverage on some other Olympians who faced strong opponents that struggled. It looked almost as if it was a PR video, one that advertises the two Olympic medalists. There are such athletes who triumphed in the Beijing games but were on the wrong end of an upset from other talented domestic competition. Perhaps this could be whole another story, but for some people who are only able to catch this news video, it might have been more diverse to add about 20 seconds and add that aspect to the story.

If this story was a “text-only story,” I think it might not even have caught the attention of may news spectators, especially because it’s about sports. One great thing about visual coverage of sports is that it is always more exciting and gives you a sense of actually being there. Also, through video and familiar scenes (for example, Park swimming past the leader to finish first) reminiscence of these figures and their accomplishments could be duplicated, thus making it a story with more impact. I think that’s why we have more analysis and projections in the text version of a sports story.

Monday, October 13, 2008

Video Example Critique

I watched a news video on CNN.com entitled "Healthy fast food."  It presented Atlanta Area Fresh 'n Fit Cuisine, a healthy fast food-to-go option, focusing on Tiffany Hoffine's experience with the business.  The reporter interviewed Hoffine and showed clips of her walking out of the a discount nutrition store with the food, getting in her car, bringing it home to her husband, and eating it at the table as a nice meal.  She also interviewed the chef at the company, showing the kitchen and the food being made, along with an interview with a registered dietician.  It was a pretty good video.  I would have liked to see interviews withe more Fresh 'n Fit Cuisine customers.  Does this company just benefit a couple with no kids?  Could a family use this?  Hoffine mentioned that she had already lost ten pounds and the chef said that the company caters to 1,200 and 2,000 calorie diets.  Is this for people who want to lose weight or is that just a side benefit?

As for the B-roll, I feel like it was a little unnecessary to show Hoffine physically walking out of the store with her food, opening her car door, getting into her car, etc.  I think it would have been a better visual to show all of the different food options in the store and show her deciding which to buy.  They also could have included in the story different places were the food is available.

It was a little corny also when Hoffine used lines such as "Honey, I'm home!" when she brought home the food to her husband and "Bon appetit!" when they sat down to eat it.  It seemed unnatural, like she was clearly acting for the camera.  The camera didn't seem to be merely a fly on the wall. 

This story would not have been as strong as a text only story.  People need a visual of food; something they are going to be eating needs to look appealing.  It was also important to get a look into the kitchen.  The food appeared to be high-quality and the fact that the couple sat down in the dining room with the food on their nice plates, drinking wine added an element that would have been harder to pick up on with just words.  If the story was only told in words it would have to rely much more heavily on sensory words and descriptions.  

"The Milkman"

As I went to search for multimedia videos, I found many Associated Press examples or actual clips from a local broadcast news station. I did not want to critique these because they were not solely meant for the web. You could find them on TV, just by turning on the nightly news. Instead, I turned to the St. Louis Post Dispatch and found a video of a story by Elie Gardner - titled "The Milkman."
http://videos.stltoday.com/p/video?id=2279691

This story discusses a male "lactation" counselor at a children's store in St. Louis. While a text narrative could have given us more information about the store and Eric Nemens, the counselor, it would have lost the visual effect of babies being fed by their mothers; with bright eyes and happy faces, it's easier to understand what Nemens is discussing about the bond with a baby. The reporter timed Nemens' questions perfectly about being a father - she added ambience noise of babies cooing and crying, as well as excerpts from Howie Day's song, Collide. It gives a strong visual about the bond between a parent and a newborn.

I wish the reporter would have covered more about the irony of having a male as a "lactation" counselor; this appears to be unique, so how do the mothers feel asking him for advice? Where is their voice within this story? It becomes very one-sided. While we learn about why Nemens enjoys working with children, we completely lose the aspect of the unique situation. I think more interviews would be needed. While these interviews may be in a text form of the story, at least some short clip would have been beneficial.

Additionally, it would be nice to see some interactions between Nemens and the new mothers. As viewers, we can see the mothers conversing with one another, but that isn't what the story is about. We need to see a better visual of Nemens, and I think that would lead to a better overall understanding.

I like the way newspaper websites are trying to stay up-to-date with our modern age. With opportunities for readers to visually see their stories, newspaper corporations can stay alive in our fast paced world!!

Pay It Forward

I found a video article on CNN.com entitled "Man fills strangers gas tanks".  The title is interesting in itself because it leaves the consumer asking questions and therefore increases the probability that they'll click the link.  One may wonder why would a man do such a deed for someone he barely knows in today's self-centered society but questions such as this are immediately answered as "Dave" of Portland, Oregon is revealed in the two-and-a-half-minute clip.

The video tells the tale of a man who fills strangers' tanks randomly on his own time, only asking the recipients to "pay it forward" or "do what they can within their budget for someone else".  What makes this clip work is the fact that the man's actions are so genuine and rare they produce opposite positive emotions.  And hopefully positive actions by the recipients in the future.

I enjoyed this story because it was an easily digestible at 2:37 and offered a complete picture of the situation.  Missing information included David's last name, names of interviewees, among other small things.  But overall, the story is very satisfying and complete.

http://www.cnn.com/video/?JSONLINK=/video/us/2008/10/11/natpkg.or.gas.pay.forward.kgw

Kevin Ornduff

Video Example Critique - Tomeka Weatherspoon

The New York Times has a video story called, "The Women of Parkour," which is on their Web site. Parkour is defined as the art of moving efficiently. The story focuses on a select group of women who have been invading the sport. The men and women practice in a park-like atmosphere, performing various stunts and acrobatic moves.

It is a very visually appealing, while still offering a solid explanation of the sport.

There were weak spots in the interviews and lack of basic information about the story's setting. Though men and women were featured doing stunts, only women were interviewed. Of those only one name was credited. Specifics such as location and date were simply left out. These could have quickly been explained using narration.

The story would not have translated well through text. The most interesting aspect is in how unique their techniques look. It may be impossible to explain those kinds of images using words.

You can find the story here: http://video.on.nytimes.com 

Journalistic Video

To analyze a piece of journalistic video, I chose to view something a little less hard-hitting and impactuful. I chose to watch a short interest story from MSNBC. The story was about a 14-year-old eagle that was captured and raised in captivity. But the owners decided to release the bird into the wild, even though the bird had never flown. The owners trained for a year on hang-gliders and finally released the eagle from the top of a French mountain while gliding alongside it.

The visuals in the story are absolutely stunning. Helicopter shots set the scene around the mountain and a videographer clearly rode in a hang-glider as well to capture some amazing footage. None of the shots lasted for longer than 5 seconds, which kept the audience interested and engage.

The narrator was simple and clearly and concisely told the story in an effective way. I would, however, liked to hear some more original voices in the story. This was meant to be a quick and painless story, and I understand that, but why couldn't the network interviewed at least one person. They had video of the person, so I think a sound bite should have been included. Original voices bring an authenticity to the story I feel is lacking thus far. I would have liked to know the outcome of the flight also. The scene was wonderfully set, but then not really explored through to completion.

I quite enjoyed this brief story, but clearly there is room for improvement.

The link to the video story: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/27163150#%2327163150